Fantasy team judging

[Nick]

Hey guys, these are the teams that were completed (and rosters filed in) from the killing-time Fantasy draft, we'd really appreciate it if you could skim the teams and make note of the 2 you think would meet in the stanley cup finals. The emphasis here in on the playoffs, perhaps in a long hard series (as is typical in the playoffs amongst two healthy teams). Pay no attention to conference, just assume the two best teams wouldn't meet until the finals. If you'd like to comment with who you believe the winner would be, and perhaps what you liked about the teams that would also be a plus.

Team 1:

Team 2:

Clowe - Malkin - Kane
Ruutu - Briere - Havlat
Okposo - Berglund - Boyes
Talbot - Konopka - Fehr

Lidstrom - Kronwall
Whitney - Carle
Phillips - Brewer

Halak
Niemi

Bench: Franson, A. Stewart

Team 3:

Line 1: Patrick Marleau - Eric Staal - Daniel Alfredsson
Line 2: Marian Gaborik - Mike Richards - Dustin Brown
Line 3: Jamie Benn - Mike Fisher - Ryan Callahan
Line 4: Tyler Ennis - Ryan O'Reilly - Nathan Gerbe
Bench: Sean Avery

Pairing 1: Andrei Markov - Robyn Regehr
Pairing 2: Brooks Orpik - Sergei Gonchar
Pairing 3: Josh Gorges - Hall Gill
Bench: Keith Ballard

Tandem: Dwayne Roloson - Jean-Sebastien Giguere
Bench: Semyon Varlamov

Team 4:

--
--
--
--
-
-------------------
-------------------
-
-
-

--------------------
--------------------

Team 5:

Team 6:

Rick Nash-Mike Ribeiro-David Perron

Alexander Ovechkin-Andy McDonald-Mark Recchi

Steve Downie-Jason Arnott-Matt Cooke

Colon Orr-Kyle Turris-George Parros

Max Pacioretty-Arron Asham


Christian Ehrhoff-Dennis Seidenberg

Erik Johnson-Cam Fowler

Nicklas Grossman-Mark Fistric

John Scott

Goalies

Marc-André Fleury
Kari Lehtonen

Team 7:

--
--
--
--

-
-
-

Team 8:

Heatley -Thornton - St Louis
Smyth - Duchence - Hemsky
Hall - Vermette - Cole
Brouwer - Kennedy - D'Agostini
Tanguay - Campbell

Myers - Staal
Cambell - Hamhius
Kubina - Zidlicky
Oduya

Vokoun
Backstrom

Team 9:

Cammalleri - Roy - Iginla*C*
Booth - Koviu*A* - Horton
Steen - Zajac - Lupul
Bickell - Filppula - Versteeg

Bouwmeester - Weber*A*
J.Johnson - Boychuk
Kulikov - Hamonic

Miller
Reimer

Extras: Brandon Prust, Brayden Schenn, & Keith Aulie

Please do not talk about which GM picked which team until the voting has finalized. Let's avoid the popularity vote and just see which team(s) people like.

[MSP4LYFE]

I wonder who team 6 is...

[Shep]

lol

[kimmer]

GO MY TEAM!

[214_Stars]

Now Paul don't go voting for yourself haha

[Scott]

Where's my team?

[kimmer]

Where's my team?

L 0 L

[anton]

fuck me i meant to vote team 4, but i did team 5 instead

[armandtanzarian]

Who took the time to put all those links together from jersey database? I would just like to tell that person that it is now summer, and you can leave the house.

[kimmer]

Who took the time to put all those links together from jersey database? I would just like to tell that person that it is now summer, and you can leave the house.

They were actually done by the team owners individually themselves (including me) while we were posting our roster in the roster thread, and then he just copied the text directly here nothing really big

EDIT: Misunderstood the question. Yes some of us owners want to make it look nice. we did it. Doesn't take long. We are anal

[Shep]

This is one thing I started out putting some work into to each playercard, but said fuck it

[armandtanzarian]

lol, i originally did it and got annoyed trying to keep up with all my changes. That is why i was amazed if one person actually did all of it. knowing that it was a shared effort is much easier to understand.

[Shep]

You should have made the votes public so we can see if any sad sack of shit voted for themself

[Nick]

i voted for myself because i think i have one of the best teams... i'd imagine lots of us did that -> tends to be how fantasy drafts work -> hence pick 2.

[kimmer]

I'm a sack of shit!

[Shep]

i voted for myself because i think i have one of the best teams... i'd imagine lots of us did that -> tends to be how fantasy drafts work -> hence pick 2.

The whole point was to have non-fantasy GMs do all the voting.

Voting for yourself, no matter what the contest, even if you think you're the best, is lame..

[Nick]

depends on what the voting is for... the concept here was just to end it in some way, on which two teams each GM believes are best. Should I lie and say that team 1 would beat mine when I don't believe it would?

I agree in many other cases, self-voters aren't great...


However the point here wasn't to have all the non-fantasy GM's doing all the voting -> i posed it to all 31 league members, figured some closure was due.

[Shep]

It was originally supposed to be the non-GMs

[214_Stars]

I'm not going to toss my vote in...till all GM's that played vote don't wanna get the freebie vote unless everyone else did it.

[Shep]

I'm not going to toss my vote in...till all GM's that played vote don't wanna get the freebie vote unless everyone else did it.

Vote for me.