PIT/FLA

[MSP4LYFE]

Ovy, Kovy, Nash, Perry, Parise -> no particular order.

I think Kessel is in this conversation, I would personally take him over Parise, Nash and Perry.

[MSP4LYFE]

Hell I'd probably take kessel over nash

If you didn't I would question your sanity. Kessel is a superior offensive player.

[Nick]

MUCH bigger group of wingers who can provide some scoring with some grind than the guys who can make plays.


Is Bergeron better than Stamkos?

I completely disagree with this. There is a reason Lucic is so highly regarded in real life, there are like one or two players who play that way in the entire NHL!

Lucic is very different from Kunitz or Hartnell though… perhaps he does belong in the top 30, as you're right he is a very rare player...personally i find he's a non-factor in too many games.

[Shep]

Ovy, Kovy, Nash, Perry, Parise -> no particular order.

1 of those makes my top 5. Maybe 2.

[kimmer]

Ovi
Perry
Kane
D.Sedin
Kovalchuk

[Tony]

We're adding ex-NHLers to the list now?

[kimmer]

shut up tony go take ur hot-ass streaking SJS players and die (whom play 2 games this week and contributed to oer 65% of your offence)

[Shep]

We're adding ex-NHLers to the list now?

I thought it was just NHLers, too.

[kimmer]

Fine then, I replace Kovalchuk with Parise

[MSP4LYFE]

For me it's: Kessel, Kane, Perry, Sedin and Ovechkin (in no particular order).

[bills09]

For me it's: Kessel, Kane, Perry, Sedin and Ovechkin (in no particular order).

I mostly agree but swap sending with parise

[kimmer]

There is no way Sedin isnt a top 5 active winger in our time no matter how much bias you might have against the twins. Of the 5 only 3 of them even sniffed the 100+ pt mark

[Tony]

Doesn't count ... the twins rely on each other for production

... plus they're ginger ... gross

[Robin Hood]

For me it's: Kessel, Kane, Perry, Sedin and Ovechkin (in no particular order).

Most accurate ranking. I would put Parise as the honourable mention

[The BBKL Insider]

Seguin could be on that list too imo, I'd drop nash for him

[Arian The Insider]

Seguin could be on that list too imo, I'd drop nash for him

he's a center

[KapG]

Kovalchuk is a traitor

Still can't believe I lost him in his prime to the khl. So upsetting it still actually pisses me off.

[Shep]

Mine is: Ovechkin, Kane, Kessel, Sedin, Parise.

HM: Zetterberg

No order.

[kimmer]

why not perry

[Tony]

Ovechkin, Kane, Perry, Parise, St.Louis

HM: Kessel, Marleau, Zetterberg