Evander Kane

[Peter]

I like to look at stats after I make trades to be pleasantly surprised

[Robin Hood]

Shiv you write that as if Plek helps you win more than G, Sid or Stammers... which was true for Crosby during our last playoffs when he was injured, and at no other time. Even that wasn't the biggest factor in my playoff loss - not having a starting goalie would be the biggest factor. I'm not even trying to bash Plek, but your point on a deeper playoff run with him leaves out a ton of information to a new GM who has no way of knowing that context.

Why do you always have to drag every conversation Sid or Stamkos LOL?

I would reject Giroux for Plekanec. 8M for that? Keep him please. I'll stick with Plekanec at 5.

[Nick]

you brought it up. not me.


Putting Plek in the same conversation as Toews, bergeron, giroux, let alone sid or stamkos is a discredit to them - as a hockey community we should defend against such actions!

[Robin Hood]

you brought it up. not me.

In all seriousness, Stamkos going down may be the best thing to happen to you. Getting 2-3 pieces for him could win you the championship

[CAM]

I remember when Kesler was the God that all was measured against in BBKL stat terms. That was soon after everyone thought i knew nothing by trading Kessel for Kesler....lol

[Robin Hood]

I hope Cliff offers Dave Henrik Sedin for Kane.

Everyone can say that's an amazing deal and Dave will get his Assists.

[Nick]

Ye - I've said it before, but I have more categories of 'success' in the BBKL than just winning the championship, I'd prefer to run a team the way I would as a GM, with prospects and players that I like, prolonged contention, being fun in NHL13*, and it's even better if I like to watch them.

[anton]

Eberle

[kimmer]

I hope Cliff offers Dave Henrik Sedin for Kane.

Everyone can say that's an amazing deal and Dave will get his Assists.

He probably should take that

[Shep]

I remember when Kesler was the God that all was measured against in BBKL stat terms. That was soon after everyone thought i knew nothing by trading Kessel for Kesler....lol

And now Kessel > Kesler by a large margin.

However, when you had Kesler, yes he was more valuable than Kessel.

[Shep]

I hope Cliff offers Dave Henrik Sedin for Kane.

Everyone can say that's an amazing deal and Dave will get his Assists.

That would be a bad trade for Dave.

[kimmer]

Also, i just realised dave put kane up there to gain assists back... I mean thats it? Lile who does that? Then that means really yes, henrik sedin wud be like the absolute best candidate lol

[Nick]

I'm not saying I'd do it, but let's be serious, Henrik Sedin is a damn nice player to have.
http://bbkl.hockey.cbssports.com/player ... :p/scoring?


7-5 categories in Kane's favour, and age, but now on the PK the twins are legit.

[anton]

we just gonna ignore the eberle offer then

[The BBKL Insider]

we just gonna ignore the eberle offer then

i'd be taking it

i quite like eberle

[Robin Hood]

we just gonna ignore the eberle offer then

I'd take that if I was Dave. But this Dave kid might call it "not close"

[Tony]

Assists? Arcobello straight up then. Rape for Dave!

[Nick]

Eberle isn't a bad offer at all in a 1:1 situation, I'd prefer kane becuase of the g/sog/hits/pims but eberle has more assists/points/stpts potential - both pk, and are awesome to own.

[kimmer]

He shud take eberle + 2nd right. Fucking. Now

Holy shit

[The BBKL Insider]

Eberle isn't a bad offer at all in a 1:1 situation, I'd prefer kane becuase of the g/sog/hits/pims but eberle has more assists/points/stpts potential - both pk, and are awesome to own.

they are actually pretty similar players to have.

On a 'real' NHL team i'd take Eberle, he's a class act here in edmonton - less baggage and off ice issues than kane.

on a bbkl team it's a toss up, both very similar in age, stats, and cap