VAN/DAL

[MSP4LYFE]

To Dallas:

Devante Smith-Pelly

To Vancouver:

Charlie Coyle

[Peter]

ya deal

[The BBKL Insider]

Solid

[shooker]

Eek I think this is a homerun for Kareem. I definitely do not put dvp on coyles level..

[Tony]

racist ...

[KapG]

muuuuuuuuuuuuuch rather coyle. I think his upside is greater than DSPs

[Peter]

Offensively, yeah Coyle's got more upside, what 50+ points maybe? but DSP could be a 40 + a ton of periphs, dsp's a guarantee for periph monster, + has upside

[MSP4LYFE]

According to Chuck Fletcher, Charlie Coyle is up to 225 llbs. now, Jesus!

[Nick]

I like this deal!

[Arian The Insider]

white guy > black guy

no racial

[Nick]

If I had either one of these prospects it would be tough to trade for the other, IMO. Given the league differences, injury, exposure, etc I'm not sure how one is entirely confident DSP>Coyle or vice-versa.

Coyle is definitely newer and shinier; but he SHOULD dominate the Q (especially with a wicked supporting staff).

DSP was def the best player on the St.Mike's

Both a very physical, both showed awesome in WJC, in their CHL playoffs they each scored consistently.

[bills09]

If I had either one of these prospects it would be tough to trade for the other, IMO. Given the league differences, injury, exposure, etc I'm not sure how one is entirely confident DSP>Coyle or vice-versa.

Coyle is definitely newer and shinier; but he SHOULD dominate the Q (especially with a wicked supporting staff).

DSP was def the best player on the St.Mike's

Both a very physical, both showed awesome in WJC, in their CHL playoffs they each scored consistently.

I would argue that Casey Cizikas was the best player on that Missisauga squad and im a huge DSP fan.

[MSP4LYFE]

Cizikas was easily the best player on the team, I live in Mississauga, and go to a ton of Majors (formerly Ice Dogs) games every year.

[Phion Keneuf]

Love it for Peter.

Great value by Kareem though.
I just like DSP and the way he headbutts the puck into the net