Trade: DET/CGY (1 of 2)

[Shoalzie]

To Detroit:

*2012 5th Rounder (TBD)

*Calgary will owe Detroit the 2013 4th Rounder (CGY) if a 2012 5th Rounder is not acquired by the start of the 2012 BBKL draft

To Calgary:

2011 6th Rounder (BOS)
2011 6th Rounder (STL)
2011 6th Rounder (TB)

[Robin Hood]

? is this trade even allowed CC?

[Shoalzie]

If there is a problem with this deal, please let me know.

[kyuss]

it's funny that you are the one asking shiv, considering you are perharps the GM that more often inserts unowned picks in deals.

Maybe wanna know if you can often use this formula as well going forward?

[Shoalzie]

I don't want to start a trend with this...I asked openly for a 2012 5th for those three picks and Frank chimed in and said he's interested. He does own his 2013 4th and I'm basically considering it as my pick until he sends a 2012 5th.

[fedro91]

To Detroit:

*2012 5th Rounder (TBD)

*Calgary will owe Detroit the 2013 4th Rounder (CGY) if a 2012 5th Rounder is not acquired by the start of the 2012 BBKL draft

To Calgary:

2011 6th Rounder (BOS)
2011 6th Rounder (STL)
2011 6th Rounder (TB)

I accept

[Robin Hood]

it's funny that you are the one asking shiv, considering you are perharps the GM that more often inserts unowned picks in deals.

Maybe wanna know if you can often use this formula as well going forward?

Mik you gotta stop with the personal attacks lol. IMO a deal like this should not be allowed. I'm pretty sure the CC ruled on this last year too.

[kyuss]

it's funny that you are the one asking shiv, considering you are perharps the GM that more often inserts unowned picks in deals.

Maybe wanna know if you can often use this formula as well going forward?

Mik you gotta stop with the personal attacks lol.

what personal attacks?

IMO a deal like this should not be allowed. I'm pretty sure the CC ruled on this last year too.

i don't think it ever did.
Btw, i'd like to hear why this deal should not be allowed IF you (and others) are allowed to trade picks they don't have.
It's the same here, only Shoa takes the care to specify what would happen in case he can't eventually provide such pick.. so, if anything, this deal is a step better than yours.

[fedro91]

I'm pretty sure this deal is good.

[Shoalzie]

As I told Frank, he's good for getting me a pick and he's got the other pick in his possession if he doesn't cash in. It's obviously more beneficial to him to get me a 2012 5th rather than having to surrender a 4th for the following year.

[Shoalzie]

Deal complete:
http://bbkl.ca/viewtopic.php?f=76&t=4200