Page 1 of 1

Looking to Downgrade a Dman

PostedCOLON Wed Oct 12, 2011 2:05 pm
by Scott
I'm looking to downgrade one of these guys for some good futures or an upgrade on forward..

Stephane Robidas(top PKer, top PP, huge shot blocker and hitter)
Lubo (top end offensive Dman with some PK time)
Dennis Wideman (looking amazing so far in WSH)
Nik Kronwall (great all around Dman with 40+ point potential. Will be DET workhorse)

PM/MSN

Re: Looking to Downgrade a Dman

PostedCOLON Wed Oct 12, 2011 2:08 pm
by Nick
All of mine are better so I cannot help you out.

Re: Looking to Downgrade a Dman

PostedCOLON Wed Oct 12, 2011 2:42 pm
by MSP4LYFE
Nick wroteCOLONAll of mine are better so I cannot help you out.
I'd take Kronwall over all of your defenceman not named Shea Weber and Dion Phaneuf, personally.

Re: Looking to Downgrade a Dman

PostedCOLON Wed Oct 12, 2011 11:44 pm
by bills09
Kronwall>>>>Macdonald.

Re: Looking to Downgrade a Dman

PostedCOLON Wed Oct 12, 2011 11:46 pm
by Scott
bills09 wroteCOLONKronwall>>>>Macdonald.
LOL, at minimum

Re: Looking to Downgrade a Dman

PostedCOLON Thu Oct 13, 2011 12:06 am
by MSP4LYFE
bills09 wroteCOLONKronwall>>>>Macdonald.
Kronwall is better, but to say that he is that much better (with cap hit taken into consideration) is an overstatement. Andrew Macdonald is a very good defenceman, both in H2H, and in real life.

Re: Looking to Downgrade a Dman

PostedCOLON Thu Oct 13, 2011 12:17 am
by bills09
For sure he is, but imo not on Kronwalls level nevermind better
but yeah i exaggerated.

Re: Looking to Downgrade a Dman

PostedCOLON Thu Oct 13, 2011 12:33 am
by Nick
MacDonald and Benn allow for Ovy & Weber... #justSayin

also, non-elc deal with 3 years left... what's Kronwall's deal going to be next year? Likely that contract talks begin around 10x Andrew's. #twitter


But fair enough, MacDonald is a #2/3 on NYI whereas Nik is #2 on the red wings, for my team it wouldn't make sense to add to MacDonald in order to get Kronwall. Every other dman i have is a #1. #WasSupposedToBeAjoke #kinda

Re: Looking to Downgrade a Dman

PostedCOLON Thu Oct 13, 2011 2:30 am
by Scott
You said "all of mine are better..." though which is obviously untrue. Nik Kronwall would no doubt be your #3/4. #ThisWayofEndingShitisFuckingGhey

Re: Looking to Downgrade a Dman

PostedCOLON Thu Oct 13, 2011 7:28 am
by Shep
MacDonald will be exposed to the plug he is by the end of the year #shutthefuckupyouuselessfuck

Re: Looking to Downgrade a Dman

PostedCOLON Thu Oct 13, 2011 12:32 pm
by Nick
Exposed? You'd think that would have happened last year when he was the #1 and the #2 was a rookie (who arguably became the #1).


As for being my #3/4...not IMO Goli, EJ, & Fowler SVP; number one's for a reason. Given all variables and the context of cap impact (in regards to cap spent on D) MacDonald too. #Neededtoqualify #betterformyteam #ilikeendingthingslikethis

Re: Looking to Downgrade a Dman

PostedCOLON Thu Oct 13, 2011 12:54 pm
by Shep
Nick wroteCOLONExposed? You'd think that would have happened last year when he was the #1 and the #2 was a rookie (who arguably became the #1).


As for being my #3/4...not IMO Goli, EJ, & Fowler SVP; number one's for a reason. Given all variables and the context of cap impact (in regards to cap spent on D) MacDonald too. #Neededtoqualify #betterformyteam #ilikeendingthingslikethis
No, Macdonald blows.

Re: Looking to Downgrade a Dman

PostedCOLON Thu Oct 13, 2011 1:44 pm
by kimmer
tbh, I wonder what Scott means by downgrading. It probably means upgrading by the end of the trade results.

Re: Looking to Downgrade a Dman

PostedCOLON Thu Oct 13, 2011 1:50 pm
by Scott
H MART wroteCOLONtbh, I wonder what Scott means by downgrading. It probably means upgrading by the end of the trade results.
You haven;t made me an offer to be able to find out.

Re: Looking to Downgrade a Dman

PostedCOLON Thu Oct 13, 2011 2:00 pm
by kimmer
I have Jovo/Morris/Coburn/Jones/Walker/Morrisonn/Russell