Buds Board Keepers League

With all the talk in Scotts thread about the best ever, who is the most under rated player of all time.

Imo its mike bossy aka purest goal scorer ever.

Real life: Ron Francis.


BBKL: the Sedin twins.

Ronny is my 2nd place finisher lol. So I like him being brought up. Another one is mike Gartner. No love for him ever.

There are lots of guys I can think of. In no particular order I'd say:

Steve Larmer
Chris Chelios
Joe Nieuwendyk
Neal Broten
Ken Daneyko
Doug Gilmour
Pierre Turgeon
Vinny Damphousse
Kevin Hatcher
Dave Andreychuk
Pat Verbeek
Bryan Trottier
Mike Gartner
Ron Francis
Michal Goulet
Andy Moog
Phil Housley
Joe Mullen
Rod Gilbert
Brendan Shannahan
Dale Hawerchuk
Mike Bossy
Bernie Federko
Dave Taylor
Dino Ciccarelli
Adam Oates
Brian Bellows
Bernie Nicholls
Darryl Sittler

The list goes on... I can't name THE most underrated, there are just too many.

The lack of Bob Gainey, Mats Sundin, Ken Linesman, Adam Foote, and Samuel Pahlsson is appalling.

Scott you are as fun as cancer. Pick one.

Lol at sundin being underrated. At best he is appropriately rated maybe a little overrated, but that's what happens when you have a hall of fame career in the biggest hockey market.

shooker wroteCOLONScott you are as fun as cancer. Pick one.

Lol at sundin being underrated. At best he is appropriately rated maybe a little overrated, but that's what happens when you have a hall of fame career in the biggest hockey market.

I also forgot Dale Hunter on that list haha

If I had to pick one I'd probably pick Dino Ciccarelli. I just loved that guy!

nice pick. I can respect that lol

shooker wroteCOLONnice pick. I can respect that lol

Unreal how he was never drafted. He was amazing in junior and nasty as fuck. Dino was a true warrior and was almost a PPGer. He played on some pretty shitty teams too lol

Love the Dino pick.

The Devil wroteCOLONThere are lots of guys I can think of. In no particular order I'd say:

Steve Larmer
Chris Chelios
Joe Nieuwendyk
Neal Broten
Ken Daneyko
Doug Gilmour
Pierre Turgeon
Vinny Damphousse
Kevin Hatcher
Dave Andreychuk
Pat Verbeek
Bryan Trottier
Mike Gartner
Ron Francis
Michal Goulet
Andy Moog
Phil Housley
Joe Mullen
Rod Gilbert
Brendan Shannahan
Dale Hawerchuk
Mike Bossy
Bernie Federko
Dave Taylor
Dino Ciccarelli
Adam Oates
Brian Bellows
Bernie Nicholls
Darryl Sittler

The list goes on... I can't name THE most underrated, there are just too many.

very good list agree with most, but id strongly disagree with shanahan, i think he was very highly regarded as one of the best total pacakge goal scorers of his generation, cant see at all how he was underrated he was about par id say

marcel dionne

Billy Smith - One of the most clutch goalies of all time.

I gtg with Adam Oates

Bruno Grevais

SuperMario wroteCOLONBruno Grevais

Dino...ugghhh...

Nick wroteCOLONDino...ugghhh...

?

The Devil wroteCOLON

Nick wroteCOLONDino...ugghhh...

?

"Damn you Dino for being such a pain in the Leafs' ass" I expect.

Mike wroteCOLON

The Devil wroteCOLON

Nick wroteCOLONDino...ugghhh...

?

"Damn you Dino for being such a pain in the Leafs' ass" I expect.

haha, ya.. but I was waiting for Nick to disagree with me.. he normally does lol

There's no denying Dino was one underrated motherfucker.