The Devil wroteCOLONshooker wroteCOLONLol how can anyone say they just don't care? This was brought up how long ago?
Trying to start the annual bbkl blow up lol
There is literally zero discussion about anything in the CC right now.. and there hasn't been for quite some time. It's rather irritating. It's been a revolving door forever..
i think there are reasons for that, and please note i'm going to talk about it without any polemic intent (sorry for this being a bit too long).
1)
The main reason perhaps is the way the whole CC thing is expected to work.
The CC brings up arguments and discuss them, only for the admin group to step in somewhere to take a decision.
And most times, being a CC member the perception is that instead of having the whole admin group discussing/examining the brought up argument, it's just you deciding accordingly to your opinion, one that rarely gets affected by the aforementioned discussion. So the perception being a CC member is that your opinion is what matters anyway, and unless you are the one asking for opinions, you already have a set one that won't be affected.
This obviously does NOT encourage discussions: why spending hours debating over something when your opinion (or the admin-group's one) might already be set on that..
speaking for my case, being called a retard and a whining pussy when i argue over something by the one who seems to be taking most decisions obviously suggests to me i should better take a step back and wait for when an opinion is asked over something that doesn't seem to be decided yet instead of wasting time (not that i have not being quite active anyway).
So this first point relates to 2 facts:
-CC members hardly have any decisions power
-the perception you (or admin-group) will take your decision no matter what, often without answering/caring-about the brought up arguments ("it's not a big deal" and "stop being pussies" are not exactly fulfilling answers).
reality might not be 100% what perception suggests, but perception is what matters as for making people to take a step back.
It's like most are just waiting for you: if you don't take part in a thread (like the "off-season agenda" one Nick started this month) the discussion stagnates waiting to realize if it's worth the time; if you join it stating your opinion is set and clear, adding to the discussion will be whining without results.
When you join and things seem to be undetermined yet, that's when people feel encouraged to contribute.
Of course, this is only one problem.
2)
lack of final step:
sometimes arguments get discussed in depth, a decision seems to be reached, but then it doesn't get 'ratified', i.e.:
- made official and clear in that particular thread by an admin group member
- announced and made official on the public forum
- added to the CBA
3)
lack of CC agenda:
the CC clearly needs some kind of schedule for things that need to be addressed.
Obviously i don't mean that a particular argument has to be discussed on a particular day, more like periods of time.
What i mean is something like this:
each admin or CC member has like a week to bring up matters that need to be addressed during the off-season.
then an admin or the CC chief makes a list of such arguments and some kind of ensuing schedule (weighing in urgency and how matters relates to each other), which means.. on week 1-7 we will discuss and decide on that, on week 8-14 we will discuss and decide on this.. and so on... i guess someone has to be accountable for releasing the agenda for that to happen (regularly in the future, not only now).
at that point, CC members know when they are expected to fill in on that argument (so they somehow become accountable for that, if a CC member often fails to do it or to explain his reasons, he gets substituted).
Until we establish an agenda, we are left to the goodwill of the day.. and it's unlikely something gets discussed and decided on one day anyway, so you already need 2 days or more of shared goodwill (and time available) in a row to reach a resolution over anything lol.
What happens instead is members tend to wait and see whatever new argument shows up, meanwhile when they have some free time to spend on the league, they will rather care about some funnier and more personal stuff: discussing trades; heck, if they don't, while they are busy thinking about the rules some of their competitors will find a good deal instead of them...
all 3 points seem very important to me.
The good news is that it seems to me all 3 can be fixed if we want (#1 seems the only delicate one), and doing that would instantly make the CC work much better.