So I don't have to MSN everyone, opinions needed

[Topher]

So here it is two guys are coming hard at Ovy, he is not a player I need to move but there have been two guys with some fantastic offers let me know your guys opinions here are the choices:

1.) Mike Riberio + Darren Helm + Blake Wheeler + James Wisniewski for Alex Ovechkin


2.) Mike Riberio + Darren Helm + Patrick Marleau + James Wisniewski for Alex Ovechkin + Josh Bailey


3.) Pavel Datsyuk + Vinny Lecavalier + Mark Giordano + Ville Leino for Alex Ovechkin

4.) None are good enough and move on



Please guys need the opinions because its best to get a vote to see where I really am at.

[Shep]

Well, I've made the mistake of trading him under market value.

I'd want two young, H2H complete studs that load up on points as well as periphery.

[KapG]

going to think some more before I vote.

[The BBKL Insider]

the best offer there is shiv's....that said, see whats out there

[shooker]

I think option 2 and imo by far the best.

[shooker]

Well, I've made the mistake of trading him under market value.

I'd want two young, H2H complete studs that load up on points as well as periphery.

young is over rated. 25-30ish NHLers are in their primes.

[Robin Hood]

guys i see a lot of BS in this forum and on msn. i cant even believe a poll is needed. its not even close LOL.

datsyuk >> ribeiro
lecavalier >> helm
giordano > wis
leino > wheeler

[Nick]

guys i see a lot of BS in this forum and on msn. i cant even believe a poll is needed. its not even close LOL.

datsyuk >> ribeiro
lecavalier >> helm
giordano > wis
leino > wheeler

LOL... your jokes shiv.

[Shep]

Well, I've made the mistake of trading him under market value.

I'd want two young, H2H complete studs that load up on points as well as periphery.

young is over rated. 25-30ish NHLers are in their primes.

I didn't mean too young.

[Robin Hood]

guys i see a lot of BS in this forum and on msn. i cant even believe a poll is needed. its not even close LOL.

datsyuk >> ribeiro
lecavalier >> helm
giordano > wis
leino > wheeler

LOL... your jokes shiv.

LOL this poll proves that BBKL is a league where 10 gms play against each other and manipulate 20 other gms. Isn't Chris your friend?

[KapG]

guys i see a lot of BS in this forum and on msn. i cant even believe a poll is needed. its not even close LOL.

datsyuk >> ribeiro
lecavalier >> helm
giordano > wis
leino > wheeler

LOL... your jokes shiv.

its not that far off.

datsyuk >> ribeiro for sure.
lecavalier > helm (regardless of the fact vinny makes more)
giordano vs wis I might give the nod to wis. However, giordano is a beast.
leino and wheeler would be close to a wash. Although the argument could be made for either depending on what you see in each player.


I voted for shiv. I would probably wait to see what is out there a bit longer though. It's not like his value is going to suddenly drop.

[Robin Hood]

by the way Chris in option #2 you lose bailey. In option #3 you keep him. so option #3 MINUS option #2 =

Datsyuk + Lecavalier + Giordano + Leino + Bailey

vs

Marleau + Ribeiro + Wis + Helm

[Shep]

I voted to see what's out there..

Option 2 without Bailey might be enticing.

[Scott]

Easily option 2 but that's because I wouldn't touch Vinny and his contract with a 10 foot poll.

But I can and will beat all of the above

[Nick]

Shiv, not getting into a 1v1 with you here.. i think my offer kicks the shit out of yours. I don't believe you've checked the cbs/h2h stats... ending it there.

[Robin Hood]

Lets analyze trades without bias:

Trade 1
Team A: Datsyuk
Team B: Ribeiro

Trade 2
Team A: Lecavalier
Team B: Helm

Trade 3
Team A: Giordano
Team B: Wisneiwski

Trade 4
Team A: Leino
Team B: Wheeler

Trade 5
Team A: Datsyuk + Lecavalier + Bailey
Team B: Marleau + Ribeiro

In each trade, Team A either wins or ties. Whoever says no is either an idiot or lying. The amount of politics in bbkl is disgusting.

[Nick]

Shiv I dunno how anyone takes you seriously.

Please check some # and/or think before responding... might be weird for you to not be proven wrong though.... pretty big trend in progress.

[Robin Hood]

Shiv, not getting into a 1v1 with you here.. i think my offer kicks the shit out of yours. I don't believe you've checked the cbs/h2h stats... ending it there.

keep going nick. you should be ashamed of yourself if chris is your friend.

[shooker]

Shiv, not getting into a 1v1 with you here.. i think my offer kicks the shit out of yours. I don't believe you've checked the cbs/h2h stats... ending it there.

keep going nick. you should be ashamed of yourself if chris is your friend.

didnt you hear kareem none of us are friends

[armandtanzarian]

I think they are close but I personally like Shiv's offer. I also agree with Scotts assessment on salary. With that said Vinny would be a valuable guy to a team in a rebuild, so he does hold value.