Buds Board Keepers League

Sabres trade

Anthony Cirelli
John Gibson
Jonathan Gruden
Rem Pitlick
Gregory Hofmann
Nicolas Caamano
Dennis Gilbert
Dillon Hamaliuk
Alexander Pashin
Tyler Tucker
2021 3rd rounder (BUF)

Kraken trade

Jack Campbell
Noel Acciari
Nico Sturm
Nick Foligno
Derek Forbort
2022 1st rounder (LAK)

Biggest trade I’ve made in a long time! Good talks David.

Confirmed

Great chats, this is probably the biggest hockey related trad ever made since trading away 3/4 of my floor hockey team in high school for 3/4 of another team.

Lots to digest. Jeeze lol

Gibson + 3rd for campbell + 1st
Gibson is great but costs way more and being on a terrible team makes his stats bad the past few seasons. If Campbell continues putting up current stats it's good for Matt, but also gives good stability to Vegas.

Cirelli for acciari + forbort + foligno + sturm

Acciari is a value monster. 1.6m cap and like a top 40 center. Forbort does big periphs. Foligno gets pretty good stats but is older. Cirelli had a down year hopefully he bounces back.

Then there is a bunch of stuff in this deal no one knows anything about

This works for both teams, if vegas isn't planning to compete right away.

Matthew wroteCOLONGibson + 3rd for campbell + 1st
Gibson is great but costs way more and being on a terrible team makes his stats bad the past few seasons. If Campbell continues putting up current stats it's good for Matt, but also gives good stability to Vegas.

Cirelli for acciari + forbort + foligno + sturm

Acciari is a value monster. 1.6m cap and like a top 40 center. Forbort does big periphs. Foligno gets pretty good stats but is older. Cirelli had a down year hopefully he bounces back.

Then there is a bunch of stuff in this deal no one knows anything about

I like to call all that extra stuff canon fodder. Basically filler for my franchise. Gibson is putting up worse numbers, although mostly because like you said the Ducks suck right now, but he is also a little younger so fits my team a little better, even though it's only 2 years. Cirelli also brings more top 6 youth to my center core, with Thomas and steel being the other 2 young guns, so the future down the middle should be good.

As far as all the prospects and depth guys, we went back and forth on quite a few names, and I happen to like most of the guys I'm getting. Some have broken in, although only part time, but getting in the door is the hardest part. Lots of prospects that could pan out. I think this deal helps both my team and BUF.

Like this for Matt a lot….step in the right direction for a 5 peat

mmh, 2 good pieces for 5 NHLers and a 1st?

kyuss wroteCOLONmmh, 2 good pieces for 5 NHLers and a 1st?

I didn't realize there was only 2 pieces coming my way, could have sworn I had more coming my way in the deal.

Another swing and a miss for the Kraken.

Da_Hawks wroteCOLONAnother swing and a great move towards the future for the Kraken.

FTFY

Can't say that I like Seattle's side of this one.

Yeah I don’t like this where’s the trade buddy

bills09 wroteCOLONYeah I don’t like this where’s the trade buddy

Lmao bruyns is the trade buddy

I'm not as sold on Campbell as some seem to be. Sturm is meh, Foligno can be a good pickup at the right price on the right team and if healthy, Accairi and Forbort are good BBKL but bad NHL pieces.

TLDR: I think theres a lot of risk on both sides that evens this out somewhat and can see why both are interested in it

Yeah cirelli had a down year but he's only 23 and after the 19-20 season a lot of people were touting him as the next great 2 way forward and potential selke nominee type player in the future

Matthew wroteCOLON

bills09 wroteCOLONYeah I don’t like this where’s the trade buddy

Lmao bruyns is the trade buddy

Was, he has been here long enough and is in ADHL and NHLDL not an inexperienced GM.

I think Matthew broke it down pretty well. I’m taking a risk on Campbell that he is a super late bloomer, Gibson is younger and the superior goalie he has a track record of elite play when he has a half decent team and sets Seattle up long term.

Cirelli was 24th best C last year at 22 years old. No Kucherov hurt his stats a bit but this is a core piece and a young do it all C of course it’s going to be costly. Kraken gets the two best pieces and a bunch of minor league depth since he has almost none. I think Gruden and Tucker have upside, Hamaliuk Sharks used a 2nd on and Hofmann is a wild card who could step right into the Blue Jackets lineup. Pitlick and Caamano are close to breaking in as everyday guys. A couple pieces pan out and he is looking good.

I got all depth that’s at the bottom of my lineup and pieces that teams didn’t view as valuable enough to protect so no one can pretend I got all this value. I got financial flexibility and depth. For the past couple years I’ve had incredible injury luck and zero quality depth and wanted to change that for this season.

Bruyns just jinxed it, half his team is out for 6 months next year.

DApolloS wroteCOLONBruyns just jinxed it, half his team is out for 6 months next year.

Bruyns wroteCOLON

Matthew wroteCOLON

bills09 wroteCOLONYeah I don’t like this where’s the trade buddy

Lmao bruyns is the trade buddy

Was, he has been here long enough and is in ADHL and NHLDL not an inexperienced GM.

I think Matthew broke it down pretty well. I’m taking a risk on Campbell that he is a super late bloomer, Gibson is younger and the superior goalie he has a track record of elite play when he has a half decent team and sets Seattle up long term.

Cirelli was 24th best C last year at 22 years old. No Kucherov hurt his stats a bit but this is a core piece and a young do it all C of course it’s going to be costly. Kraken gets the two best pieces and a bunch of minor league depth since he has almost none. I think Gruden and Tucker have upside, Hamaliuk Sharks used a 2nd on and Hofmann is a wild card who could step right into the Blue Jackets lineup. Pitlick and Caamano are close to breaking in as everyday guys. A couple pieces pan out and he is looking good.

I got all depth that’s at the bottom of my lineup and pieces that teams didn’t view as valuable enough to protect so no one can pretend I got all this value. I got financial flexibility and depth. For the past couple years I’ve had incredible injury luck and zero quality depth and wanted to change that for this season.

I guess I'm just not nearly as optimistic about the prospects exchanging hands as you are and Gibson is not in a good situation at all. At least Seattle has a goalie that is the unquestioned starter and will get a ton of games save for injury.

Matthew wroteCOLON

bills09 wroteCOLONYeah I don’t like this where’s the trade buddy

Lmao bruyns is the trade buddy

I laughed … like an evil laugh…out loud…by myself in my bedroom lol

Edit: as for the trade. Some risk on both sides. Have seen waaaaaaaaay worse and made way worse lol.