Buds Board Keepers League

Toews for Stamkos straight up would be legit for sure

I think Mike Green's never gonna be the same so ya easy to reject Karim's offer.

gooker wroteCOLONToews for Stamkos straight up would be legit for sure

I think Mike Green's never gonna be the same so ya easy to reject Karim's offer.

Mike Green was on pace for over 50 points last year, and is on pace for 45 points this season, with periphs. He may not be the ppg super-star he was 4 years ago, but he is still a phenomenal H2H defenceman. Outside of Subban and Karlsson, Green scores as much as any defenceman.

Letang?

*not an offer, response to Kareem's assertion

Pavelski + Kunitz + was asked of me by Nick. Not that I blame him but I'm definitely not in that ballpark on Stamkos.

whats the plus?

cliff11 wroteCOLONwhats the plus?

Wasn't discussed as I said it was too rich for me.

Mike wroteCOLONLetang?

*not an offer, response to Kareem's assertion

Backes + Letang, you sir are too kind. Weird... that *edit happened while I was quoting... very sneaky

Mike wroteCOLONLetang?

Letang has only ever approached PPG numbers once in his career, and it was through 35 games. I need a larger sample size before I am comfortable putting him in the class of Subban and Karlsson offensively, but I certainly wouldn't discredit the possibility that he does so in the future.

edit: Subban has only ever done the same over a half season too, so I suppose on that basis, you are correct in naming Letang.

eberle still far and away the most legit guy in any of these offers

10-11 .61 ppg in 82 gp
11-12 .82 ppg in 51 gp
12-13 1.1 ppg in 35 gp

10-11 .49 ppg in 77 gp
11-12 .44 ppg in 81 gp
12-13 0.9 ppg in 42 gp

Mike wroteCOLON10-11 .61 ppg in 82 gp
11-12 .82 ppg in 51 gp
12-13 1.1 ppg in 35 gp

10-11 .49 ppg in 77 gp
11-12 .44 ppg in 81 gp
12-13 0.9 ppg in 42 gp

Refer to edit.

SuperMario wroteCOLONPavelski + Kunitz + was asked of me by Nick. Not that I blame him but I'm definitely not in that ballpark on Stamkos.

I wouldn't have done those 2 without a +, let alone.. a +

anton wroteCOLONeberle still far and away the most legit guy in any of these offers

Peter 3/4 mentioned Karlsson.

karlsson is super prone to achilles tendon severings - too risky

For the love of god trade him to the west ...

Blues GM wroteCOLON

SuperMario wroteCOLONPavelski + Kunitz + was asked of me by Nick. Not that I blame him but I'm definitely not in that ballpark on Stamkos.

I wouldn't have done those 2 without a +, let alone.. a +

Yup, how I feel. But I know Nick will get paid by someone.

If this thread proves anything, it is that there is no agreed upon values for players, lol.

i'd do it for karlsson

Btw - obviously Stamkos is super elite, but losing 3 great H2Hers for him is not intelligent for any franchise IMO. The winner of this auction will either have to be super rich with assets (e.g. Steve/Mike) or will have to flip Stamkos eventually to recover the depth lost. Of course I say this as a team that has no depth, so maybe my perspective is skewed.

MSP4LYFE wroteCOLONIf this thread proves anything, it is that there is no agreed upon values for players, lol.

And that's the beauty of it.