Buds Board Keepers League

For me, he's draftable because he is still eligible for the NHL draft and was 20 on December 31st. We shall see what they say.

dave1959 wroteCOLONas far as I'm concerned the wording in the current CBA is correct.

It was even discussed by CC back in 2017

So can I draft Edmonds?

dave1959 wroteCOLON1. ENTRY DRAFT (June 1st each year, beginning at 10am EDST)

These are the updated rules currently in the CBA:

1-1 : Players who turn eighteen (18) years of age before the fifteenth of September and are no older than twenty (20) years of age by the thirty-first of December are eligible for selection.

looks like the CBA was never updated on this, we've been using the regulations announced at the top of the draft thread for many years now, with the intent of adhering more closely to the NHL rules (the rule you quoted above would instead cut short the eligibility life of prospects). The reason we didn't just copy and paste from the NHL CBA is that those rules were even more complicated.

However, I see now that with the red asterisk in those regulations I probably created a difference between our eligibility rules and the NHL ones. That was an example made to clarify and solve potential grey areas, but the NHL apparently considers the player needs to have played 1 season in N.A. at age 20 (or 18, or 19) not 1 game for him to lose his eligibility at 21 rather than at 22.

So my understanding is that if we stick with what we announced at the top of each draft thread, Edmonds can't be drafted in BBKL even if he is eligible in the NHL. The purpose of embracing that rule was however to make BBKL-un-owned players eligible for our draft if they are in the NHL.

draft should be paused while we make a decision btw

Mik, if you read the thread I posted, you'll see where I did have it, and was told to change it.

The BBKL Insider wroteCOLON

DApolloS wroteCOLONHe was born January 27th, 2001. He would not be eligible as he has played in North America

This rule says otherwise:

Players who turn eighteen (18) years of age before the fifteenth of September and are no older than twenty (20) years of age by the thirty-first of December are eligible for selection.

He would have been 20 on the 31st day of December.

I think you're misreading this.

The 31st of December comment applies to the current draft year, so 2022. He'll be 21 this on 12/31/2022.

The reason Edmonds is eligible for the NHL draft is because he has not been drafted, and did not play a year in North America as an 18, 19 or 20 year old. He played as a 21 year old. So, he falls into a hole in the NHL CBA. Technically, the CBA says that all players over 18 are eligible UNLESS they meet 5 criteria to make them ineligible. Edmonds meets none of those criteria.

Brian wroteCOLON

The BBKL Insider wroteCOLON

DApolloS wroteCOLONHe was born January 27th, 2001. He would not be eligible as he has played in North America

This rule says otherwise:

Players who turn eighteen (18) years of age before the fifteenth of September and are no older than twenty (20) years of age by the thirty-first of December are eligible for selection.

He would have been 20 on the 31st day of December.

I think you're misreading this.

The 31st of December comment applies to the current draft year, so 2022. He'll be 21 this on 12/31/2022.

The reason Edmonds is eligible for the NHL draft is because he has not been drafted, and did not play a year in North America as an 18, 19 or 20 year old. He played as a 21 year old. So, he falls into a hole in the NHL CBA. Technically, the CBA says that all players over 18 are eligible UNLESS they meet 5 criteria to make them ineligible. Edmonds meets none of those criteria.

This

I was just going to post that dates are for THIS draft year.

Sorry, I didn't realize the draft was locked on purpose.

CC has ruled the pick ineligible.

Draft will be unlocked and continue on.

Selection thread re-opened, Seattle is on the clock (I believe VAN and ARZ are still skipping)

Tbone messaged for otc

Looking for a upcoming pick at a reasonable price.

Nice pik Mik, was between Jellvik and Forsell for my pick.

yeah when I saw Forsell drafted just before my pick I got a shiver about that lol

Thoms up I believe?

Also 150 in the tracker should read Colorado

Yeah, I had it Montreal from you instead.

Nice pick Mik. Was considering trading back in for Jellvik.

Had no idea he was this popular tbh

Hard to ignore the output and the BU commit helps his case too. My last pick in the 4th I was on Jellvik and switched to Johansson at the very last second.