Page 2 of 2
Re: I'm Staying.. Oh, and Trade (I'm dumb): FLA/NJD
PostedCOLON Thu Sep 23, 2010 10:00 am
by MSP4LYFE
mr. bruin wroteCOLONBergeron is going to get 65+ points this year...along with near league lead in SHTOI and FOW. All i got to say...lol And draft picks are way overrated. With that said i had great discussions with Chris and in hindsight i am glad the deal fell through. So you know what i offered for Carter to compare..Scott clearly beat me out but i feel Urbom is just another stay at home defenseman that won't hold the value that a Gormley or Elliot will bring in H2H with our setup. I think Gormley will be another Jay Bouwmeester (minus last season:))
Patrice Bergeron
Brandon Gormley or Stefan Elliot
Benn Ferreiro
Oscar Lindberg or Lovecchio
1st 2012
4th 2012
7th 2011
I'm SHOCKED both Nick, and Chris (as well as probably one or two others) turned that down. It is a phenonomenal package IMO.
Re: I'm Staying.. Oh, and Trade (I'm dumb): FLA/NJD
PostedCOLON Thu Sep 23, 2010 10:11 am
by Florida Chris
MSP4LYFE wroteCOLONFlorida Chris wroteCOLONMSP4LYFE wroteCOLONThats brutal Chris...
Really, I thought it was a pretty good return....Antropov isn't all that far behind Carter when all categories are added up...I think the picks and prospects makes up the difference, and help set me up nicely in the future.
I guess we'll see going forward, I thought Kyle's offer was superior...Hence the trade.
Anyways, my problem with this deal isn't so much what you got in return for Carter (although I wouldn't have taken it personally), it was what you gave up initially (Neal, Giroux, Yandle, Weiss), you put those players on your team now and you are among the top contenders, IMO.
Oh I got burned on the original deal...no argument there...It was the worst trade I've done, and learned from it..lol I tried to instantly get completive, and went about it wrong...I have made a number of trades since, where I think I have been patiently improving my whole team including my futures since....
Re: I'm Staying.. Oh, and Trade (I'm dumb): FLA/NJD
PostedCOLON Thu Sep 23, 2010 10:19 am
by Florida Chris
I'm SHOCKED both Nick, and Chris (as well as probably one or two others) turned that down. It is a phenonomenal package IMO.[/quote]
It was a phenonomenal package, and I was very very close to accepting it.
I took a good hard look at my team, and in the end the decision to accept Scotts offer came down to the assets my team already has, and the direction I am turning my team to..In the end I could of really flipped a coin, but when I analyzed both offers over and over again, I always seem to get a extra 1st out of scotts deal...
Re: I'm Staying.. Oh, and Trade (I'm dumb): FLA/NJD
PostedCOLON Thu Sep 23, 2010 10:20 am
by MSP4LYFE
Florida Chris wroteCOLONOh I got burned on the original deal...no argument there...It was the worst trade I've done, and learned from it..lol I tried to instantly get completive, and went about it wrong...I have made a number of trades since, where I think I have been patiently improving my whole team including my futures since....
Fair enough.
Re: I'm Staying.. Oh, and Trade (I'm dumb): FLA/NJD
PostedCOLON Thu Sep 23, 2010 12:16 pm
by Nick
Mike Richards has never been traded... I don't see a reason approaching that'll change that.
Re: I'm Staying.. Oh, and Trade (I'm dumb): FLA/NJD
PostedCOLON Thu Sep 23, 2010 12:40 pm
by armandtanzarian
Nick knows I tried...Thats all a fella can do. I know now that I traded Bergeron he will be Pierre's monster every game. I figured with my luck that is how it would go but as long as he is still a Bruin I guess its win win.
Re: I'm Staying.. Oh, and Trade (I'm dumb): FLA/NJD
PostedCOLON Thu Sep 23, 2010 3:18 pm
by Shep
Carter sucks.
Re: I'm Staying.. Oh, and Trade (I'm dumb): FLA/NJD
PostedCOLON Thu Sep 23, 2010 3:38 pm
by Robin Hood
hong57 wroteCOLON
so it is...
To FLA
Nik Antropov
Alex Urbom
Quinton howden
2011 1st round draft pick (NJD)
2011 1st round draft pick (OTT)
2012 1st round draft pick (STL)
2012 4th round draft pick (NJD)
2012 6th round draft pick (NJD)
Jack Johnson
Eric Tangradi
Ryan McDonagh
Zack Stortini
2010 6th Rounder (NJD)
To New Jersey:
Jeff Carter
Stephen Weiss
James Neal
Claude Giroux
Keith Yandle
Travis Morin
That's unbelievable.
Re: I'm Staying.. Oh, and Trade (I'm dumb): FLA/NJD
PostedCOLON Thu Sep 23, 2010 5:10 pm
by Scott
SuperMario wroteCOLONhong57 wroteCOLON
so it is...
To FLA
Nik Antropov
Alex Urbom
Quinton howden
2011 1st round draft pick (NJD)
2011 1st round draft pick (OTT)
2012 1st round draft pick (STL)
2012 4th round draft pick (NJD)
2012 6th round draft pick (NJD)
Jack Johnson
Eric Tangradi
Ryan McDonagh
Zack Stortini
2010 6th Rounder (NJD)
To New Jersey:
Jeff Carter
Stephen Weiss
James Neal
Claude Giroux
Keith Yandle
Travis Morin
That's unbelievable.
lol
