Your worst trade?

[hong57]

Must be this...

To Minnesota:

Milan Michalek
2011 2nd Rounder (SJS)
Eric Mestery
Marcel Goc

To San Jose:

Cal Clutterbuck
Brent Burns
Peter Olvecky
2010 4th Rounder (MIN)

[Mike]

My four worst trades, in chronological order. Fun note, I've made 226 trades.

June 25 2009
To TOR: 134 '09 + 141 '09 + 152 '09 + 171 '09, TBL 3rd '10
To TBL (then PHI): M. Grabovski

August 19 2009
To TOR: J. Bailey + NYI 3rd '10
To NYI: B. Richards

October 5 2009
To TOR: V. Sobotka + BOS 1st '11 + BOS 6th '11
To BOS: B. Seabrook

May 15 2010
To TOR: O. Moller
To NJD: B. Smith

[Scott]

I've made some bad ones but my worst? Probably overpaying Berger for Nash because I wanted the Knights team together

To New Jersey: Rick Nash
To Vancouver: Logan Couture, Mikael Granlund, Carter Ashton, Ryan McDonagh, Kimmo Timonen, BUF 1st '11 & NJD 1st '11

Definitely full retard.

[MSP4LYFE]

I've made alot of bad ones, too many to post really.

[Scott]

I've made alot of bad ones, too many to post really.

LOL, I scrolled through my trade history.. I made some bone-head trades too.. it kind of was depressing.. buuuuuut, then I just went back in to my sub-forum, clicked viewtopic.php?f=14&t=342 and forgot all about them

[Arian The Insider]

something like this:

To Toronto:
Edmonton 2012 1st Rounder
Lubomir Visnovsky

To Edmonton:
Maxim Mayorov
Ron Hainsey
and some other player i don't remember

also..

To St.Louis:
Dustin Penner

To Edmonton:
Phil McRae
5th Rounder

brutal lol

[hong57]

My four worst trades, in chronological order. Fun note, I've made 226 trades.

i duno if i even made 50 trades in total

[Robin Hood]

To CBJ: Dustin Brown + Stephen Weiss + Pavel Kubina
To PIT: Evgeni Malkin + Tomas Kaberle

This is when I destroyed the team that IMO could have won the championship last year.

[Mike]

To CBJ: Dustin Brown + Stephen Weiss + Pavel Kubina
To PIT: Evgeni Malkin + Tomas Kaberle

This is when I destroyed the team that IMO could have won the championship last year.

You've made worse

[anton]

August 19 2009
To TOR: J. Bailey + NYI 3rd '10
To NYI: B. Richards

[Robin Hood]

To CBJ: Dustin Brown + Stephen Weiss + Pavel Kubina
To PIT: Evgeni Malkin + Tomas Kaberle

This is when I destroyed the team that IMO could have won the championship last year.

You've made worse

I have. But my team used to be an h2h monster: Brown, Backes, Giroux, Ott, Cooke, Doan, Oshie, Edler, Letang, Ehrhoff, O'Reilly, Datsyuk, Weiss.

This trade started my downward spiral last year. I've been trying to catch up ever since.

[Mike]

To CBJ: Dustin Brown + Stephen Weiss + Pavel Kubina
To PIT: Evgeni Malkin + Tomas Kaberle

This is when I destroyed the team that IMO could have won the championship last year.

You've made worse

I have. But my team used to be an h2h monster: Brown, Backes, Giroux, Ott, Cooke, Doan, Oshie, Edler, Letang, Ehrhoff, O'Reilly, Datsyuk, Weiss.

This trade started my downward spiral last year. I've been trying to catch up ever since.

Don't forget Nielsen (thanks )

[bills09]

this one comes to mind

To Detroit:
Devante Smith Pelly
Brian Bickell
Ondrej Roman
2011 7th Rounder (TOR)

To Ottawa:
Alex Kovalev
Travis Ehrhardt
Francis Pare

but ive made worse im sure

[Mike]

Yeah Billy, not worst trade thread-worthy...

[MSP4LYFE]

You've made worse

It was Shiv's worst deal because that was the first of multiple trades that pushed him from the best team in BBKL to the third or fourth best. Obviously he has made worse deals isolated.

[MSP4LYFE]

I have. But my team used to be an h2h monster: Brown, Backes, Giroux, Ott, Cooke, Doan, Oshie, Edler, Letang, Ehrhoff, O'Reilly, Datsyuk, Weiss.

This trade started my downward spiral last year. I've been trying to catch up ever since.

Sometimes it is worthwhile to make those types of mistakes because of the lessons they provide.

[MSP4LYFE]

I think I take the cake for worst trade...

While high I traded MSP for Quincey, and then in attempt to make up for it the next day I swapped Kyle Quincey + James Reimer to Mike for Toni Lydman. Lydman is a great H2H player, but he was not worth MSP + James Reimer.

[hong57]

You've made worse

It was Shiv's worst deal because that was the first of multiple trades that pushed him from the best team in BBKL to the third or fourth best. Obviously he has made worse deals isolated.

agree with kareem on this one..

To Los Angeles:

Niklas Backstrom
Mikko Koivu
Peter Kalus

To Minnesota:

Roberto Luongo
Kyle Turris
Kevin Westgarth
2010 3rd Rounder (LAK)

this is not my worst trade even though giving up koivu was a pain (and i duno how to value player as much before).. considering luongo is the best goalie (in the season to me) and westgarth finally becoming a good h2h guy now, this trade starts my youth movement and hopefully result will be shown this year.

[armandtanzarian]

Mine has to be with ol Frank. Brad Marchand + 3rd for Stefan Elliot. ugg....

Shawn Thornton for a 5th sucks ass
McQuaid for a 3rd blows


And Mike, you have more than made up for the Seabrook trade with me.........

To Toronto: Tim Connolly + Joe Colborne + 1st round pick 2011(FLA) + 3rd round pick 2012(BOS) + 5th round pick 2010(CGY)

To Boston: 7th overall 2010 + 3rd round pick 2010(TBL)
--------------------------------------------------------------
To Toronto: Matt Gilroy + Grant Clitsome + 2012 2nd(BOS)

To Boston: Jordan Caron

[Shoalzie]

No comment...