NYR - NSH

[kyuss]

I had a deal confirmed 1 min late (2 years ago) and it was disallowed.

are you talking about your deal with DAL that was posted (rather than confirmed) like 40' late? it doesn't sound like the same situation.

In fact back then 4 deals were rejected, and the one posted before the deadline was only rejected because it was confirmed after roster lock on fantrax (nor on the board I believe)
http://bbkl.ca/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=1206 ... 80#p240541

The league announcement thread had a pretty clear MUST and i believe that was agreed upon because there was a whole kurfuffle last year or the year before. I believe there were 2 trades that were late. One was close and the other was quite a bit over time. Both being ultimately rejected.

We are tryjng to create clear rules for a reason. And this MUST sounds quite clear.

http://bbkl.ca/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=13223#p240544
http://bbkl.ca/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=13223#p240601

I don't remember if last year something different happened that made things change.

If you click on my previous post's link, you can see by that announcement that the reason the deal posted before the deadline was rejected was that it was confirmed after roster lock.

[lightupdadarkness]

I think they are going off the new rule for this year tho Mik or at least what was posted in the thread

[CasperX22]

Here's a solution, don't be a cheap cunt and hold out til a few minutes before the deadline to post a deal. I'm pretty sure every year you do this where you have at least 1 deal to right down to the wire.

[kyuss]

I think they are going off the new rule for this year tho Mik or at least what was posted in the thread

yeah I see the announcement can be interpreted as must be both posted before the deadline and confirmed before the deadline, even if it had not been the case in the past.

Either way, up to CC decide (without my vote). I did what I could from my part, agreeing (twice) on a deal hours before the deadline.
It's far from a given I would end up on the right side of this deal anyway so at least for now the only frustration comes from the fact I had to wait (hence waste) hours on this.

[kyuss]

Here's a solution, don't be a cheap cunt and hold out til a few minutes before the deadline to post a deal.

given the situation we're discussing here, this really is hilarious

[CasperX22]

Here's a solution, don't be a cheap cunt and hold out til a few minutes before the deadline to post a deal.

given the situation we're discussing here, this really is hilarious

What's hilarious about it? I'm confused.

[dave1959]

I think they are going off the new rule for this year tho Mik or at least what was posted in the thread

yeah I see the announcement can be interpreted as must be both posted before the deadline and confirmed before the deadline, even if it had not been the case in the past.

Either way, up to CC decide (without my vote). I did what I could from my part, agreeing (twice) on a deal hours before the deadline.
It's far from a given I would end up on the right side of this deal anyway so at least for now the only frustration comes from the fact I had to wait (hence waste) hours on this.

Nothing to decide.

Deals have to be posted AND confirmed before 6 pm.

This wasn't.

[CasperX22]

I think they are going off the new rule for this year tho Mik or at least what was posted in the thread

yeah I see the announcement can be interpreted as must be both posted before the deadline and confirmed before the deadline, even if it had not been the case in the past.

Either way, up to CC decide (without my vote). I did what I could from my part, agreeing (twice) on a deal hours before the deadline.
It's far from a given I would end up on the right side of this deal anyway so at least for now the only frustration comes from the fact I had to wait (hence waste) hours on this.

Nothing to decide.

Deals have to be posted AND confirmed before 6 pm.

This wasn't.

Thanks.

[kyuss]

that sounds like mission accomplished relief lol

[CasperX22]

Will be interesting to look back and see if this non deal helps or hurts Miks chances of winning a cup.

[dave1959]

Can someone with fantrax access reverse this please

[kyuss]

Nothing to decide.

Deals have to be posted AND confirmed before 6 pm.

This wasn't.

for the record, I believe this would be the first time in league's history a deal posted before the deadline and confirmed before lock gets rejected, and it's not like in the past it was clarified you could do that.
Well, not before these
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=13223#p240544
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=13223#p240601
that seemed to suggest just that.
So I thought it would take a CC vote at least.. my bad, sorry for your troubles everyone.

[The BBKL Insider]

Will be interesting to look back and see if this non deal helps or hurts Miks chances of winning a cup.

Mine was rejected and it helped me win. Maybe the same for mik here?

[CasperX22]

Will be interesting to look back and see if this non deal helps or hurts Miks chances of winning a cup.

Mine was rejected and it helped me win. Maybe the same for mik here?

Better go snipe TJ's knees right now.

[dave1959]

From announcement thread

e: Announcement thread discussion
Postby dave1959 » Wed Mar 01, 2017 4:53 pm

REMINDER

Deadline time for trades to be posted by BOTH teams is 6 pm EST

No excuses for postings past 6 pm

[CasperX22]

From announcement thread

e: Announcement thread discussion
Postby dave1959 » Wed Mar 01, 2017 4:53 pm

REMINDER

Deadline time for trades to be posted by BOTH teams is 6 pm EST

No excuses for postings past 6 pm

[dave1959]

And, this year's announcement

Re: LEAGUE ANNOUNCEMENTS thread
Postby dave1959 » Fri Jan 19, 2018 9:55 am

2018 BBKL Trade Deadline

Monday, February 26th - 6pm EST (trade MUST be posted and confirmed) (this is the FINAL week of our regular season also)

[Matthew]

We should have a vote. No one person decides.

[dave1959]

Holy fuck...we did this last year

[Handsome&FairMike]

not sure why this is up for debate. I think I had a trade last year that was posted before the deadline, but I wasn't able to confirm it until after because of work and we reversed it. (... if you even want precedent). Not big deal.

Easy no. Follow the rules.