Page 2 of 3

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 10:04 am
by Chuck Norris
bergey wroteCOLONI'll hate this trade till the day I die but how do you say no to that offer.
I said the same thing when he offered me Filatov + 4 1sts for Nielsen last year. Ridiculous value win for you Berg!

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 10:30 am
by Robin Hood
Btw fun fact. Laich's numbers from last year:

41 Points, 120 Hits, 202 SHTOI, 664 FOW, 192 SOG, 92 BLOCKS

He puts up about 10 less points than the following players but he is just as good in every other category. And what I paid for Laich is a BARGAIN for any of the names below.

Dustin Brown
David Backes
Ryan Callahan

Image

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 10:37 am
by The BBKL Insider
fun fact

he might retire due to his injury.

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 10:51 am
by Shep
SuperMario wroteCOLONBtw fun fact. Laich's numbers from last year:

41 Points, 120 Hits, 202 SHTOI, 664 FOW, 192 SOG, 92 BLOCKS

He puts up about 10 less points than the following players but he is just as good in every other category. And what I paid for Laich is a BARGAIN for any of the names below.

Dustin Brown
David Backes
Ryan Callahan

Image
+/-, Hits, Pims, SOG, STPTS are also significantly lower...

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 10:57 am
by Robin Hood
Shep wroteCOLON
SuperMario wroteCOLONBtw fun fact. Laich's numbers from last year:

41 Points, 120 Hits, 202 SHTOI, 664 FOW, 192 SOG, 92 BLOCKS

He puts up about 10 less points than the following players but he is just as good in every other category. And what I paid for Laich is a BARGAIN for any of the names below.

Dustin Brown
David Backes
Ryan Callahan

Image
+/-, Hits, Pims, SOG, STPTS are also significantly lower...
Backes is definitely a tier above. That being said Laich puts up more SHTOI and Blocks. Laich's numbers vs. Brown/Callahan (who are treated as BBKL Gods) are retardedly close if not better. My main point was that any of those 3 players would have cost significantly more as Laich is a severely undervalued player in BBKL despite being in that conversation.

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 10:59 am
by The BBKL Insider
BACKES SUCKS

I WOULDN'T TRADE JIM O'BRIAN FOR HIM

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 11:00 am
by kimmer
I would do backlund for backes +

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 2:28 pm
by armandtanzarian
SuperMario wroteCOLON
Shep wroteCOLON
SuperMario wroteCOLONBtw fun fact. Laich's numbers from last year:

41 Points, 120 Hits, 202 SHTOI, 664 FOW, 192 SOG, 92 BLOCKS

He puts up about 10 less points than the following players but he is just as good in every other category. And what I paid for Laich is a BARGAIN for any of the names below.

Dustin Brown
David Backes
Ryan Callahan

Image
+/-, Hits, Pims, SOG, STPTS are also significantly lower...
Backes is definitely a tier above. That being said Laich puts up more SHTOI and Blocks. Laich's numbers vs. Brown/Callahan (who are treated as BBKL Gods) are retardedly close if not better. My main point was that any of those 3 players would have cost significantly more as Laich is a severely undervalued player in BBKL despite being in that conversation.
Exactly, which is why you shouldn't have been able to get your hands on him. As an owner of one of those three, you are correct in your assumptions and you got a good one on a great buy.

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 2:31 pm
by shooker
I don't think people have a problem with shiv's end in this deal per say. it is more so reactionary from how bad the Neal deal was the other day. People are using that one to judge this trade.

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 2:36 pm
by Robin Hood
shooker wroteCOLONI don't think people have a problem with shiv's end in this deal per say. it is more so reactionary from how bad the Neal deal was the other day. People are using that one to judge this trade.
You are insane. I crushed that deal. It is now Laich + Bozak for Neal + Brouwer. I would do that deal all day every day. 2 Cs for 2 Ws and an h2h stud to boot. Neal scores. That is all he does. And will he repeat last year? It's a big question. Meanwhile Laich is a guarantee to be a BBKL stud.

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 2:42 pm
by shooker
SuperMario wroteCOLON
shooker wroteCOLONI don't think people have a problem with shiv's end in this deal per say. it is more so reactionary from how bad the Neal deal was the other day. People are using that one to judge this trade.
You are insane. I crushed that deal. It is now Laich + Bozak for Neal + Brouwer. I would do that deal all day every day. 2 Cs for 2 Ws and an h2h stud to boot. Neal scores. That is all he does. And will he repeat last year? It's a big question. Meanwhile Laich is a guarantee to be a BBKL stud.
don't call me insane dude. my comment was directed as a general statement more so than how I view the trade. geez man no need to get so defensive all the time, don't treat me like Mik. Also, just because I would rather Neal + Brouwer than Laich + Bozo does not make me wrong. I feel a lot of people in here would choose that side, especially with Laich's groin injury. With his style of play, that could hurt him all year long.

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 2:44 pm
by Robin Hood
shooker wroteCOLON
SuperMario wroteCOLON
shooker wroteCOLONI don't think people have a problem with shiv's end in this deal per say. it is more so reactionary from how bad the Neal deal was the other day. People are using that one to judge this trade.
You are insane. I crushed that deal. It is now Laich + Bozak for Neal + Brouwer. I would do that deal all day every day. 2 Cs for 2 Ws and an h2h stud to boot. Neal scores. That is all he does. And will he repeat last year? It's a big question. Meanwhile Laich is a guarantee to be a BBKL stud.
don't call me insane dude. my comment was directed as a general statement more so than how I view the trade. geez man no need to get so defensive all the time, don't treat me like Mik. Also, just because I would rather Neal + Brouwer than Laich + Bozo does not make me wrong. I feel a lot of people in here would choose that side, especially with Laich's groin injury. With his style of play, that could hurt him all year long.
LOL you repeatedly call my trade terrible - then you want me to not defend it?

Okay.

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 2:45 pm
by Peter
shooker wroteCOLON
SuperMario wroteCOLON
shooker wroteCOLONI don't think people have a problem with shiv's end in this deal per say. it is more so reactionary from how bad the Neal deal was the other day. People are using that one to judge this trade.
You are insane. I crushed that deal. It is now Laich + Bozak for Neal + Brouwer. I would do that deal all day every day. 2 Cs for 2 Ws and an h2h stud to boot. Neal scores. That is all he does. And will he repeat last year? It's a big question. Meanwhile Laich is a guarantee to be a BBKL stud.
don't call me insane dude. my comment was directed as a general statement more so than how I view the trade. geez man no need to get so defensive all the time, don't treat me like Mik. Also, just because I would rather Neal + Brouwer than Laich + Bozo does not make me wrong. I feel a lot of people in here would choose that side, especially with Laich's groin injury. With his style of play, that could hurt him all year long.
Neal > Laich + Brouwer > Bozak imo

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 2:48 pm
by Robin Hood
Peter wroteCOLON
shooker wroteCOLON
SuperMario wroteCOLON
shooker wroteCOLONI don't think people have a problem with shiv's end in this deal per say. it is more so reactionary from how bad the Neal deal was the other day. People are using that one to judge this trade.
You are insane. I crushed that deal. It is now Laich + Bozak for Neal + Brouwer. I would do that deal all day every day. 2 Cs for 2 Ws and an h2h stud to boot. Neal scores. That is all he does. And will he repeat last year? It's a big question. Meanwhile Laich is a guarantee to be a BBKL stud.
don't call me insane dude. my comment was directed as a general statement more so than how I view the trade. geez man no need to get so defensive all the time, don't treat me like Mik. Also, just because I would rather Neal + Brouwer than Laich + Bozo does not make me wrong. I feel a lot of people in here would choose that side, especially with Laich's groin injury. With his style of play, that could hurt him all year long.
Neal > Laich + Brouwer > Bozak imo
Laich > Neal. Bozak > Brouwer to me. Matter of preference. But that's how I see it.

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 2:49 pm
by shooker
In this thread, I say "how" to gookers genius comment then say a general statement in summation of while people dislike this trade. It was the trade with ANA I have an issue with.... I said only this so I do not understand why you need to attack. You bash my trades too and I defend not attack the people that disagree.

End.

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 2:53 pm
by Robin Hood
shooker wroteCOLONIn this thread, I say "how" to gookers genius comment then say a general statement in summation of while people dislike this trade. It was the trade with ANA I have an issue with.... I said only this so I do not understand why you need to attack. You bash my trades too and I defend not attack the people that disagree.

End.
If you attack a trade/a player that I have acquired, you better believe that I will challenge you to defend your stance. It's not personal.

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 5:50 pm
by kyuss
shooker wroteCOLON don't call me insane dude. my comment was directed as a general statement more so than how I view the trade. geez man no need to get so defensive all the time, don't treat me like Mik.
i.e.:
1. don't treat me as bad as you treat Mik (meh)
2. don't treat me like Mik does (bad?!)
3. don't treat me as if i was attacking you like Mik does (uh?)
4. don't treat me as if i was insane like Mik (proud!)

plenty of options here, anyone care to give me the odds? :)

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 5:53 pm
by KapG
Number 1

No odds. Just the answer

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 5:56 pm
by The BBKL Insider
kyuss wroteCOLON
shooker wroteCOLON don't call me insane dude. my comment was directed as a general statement more so than how I view the trade. geez man no need to get so defensive all the time, don't treat me like Mik.
i.e.:
1. don't treat me as bad as you treat Mik (meh)
2. don't treat me like Mik does (bad?!)
3. don't treat me as if i was attacking you like Mik does (uh?)
4. don't treat me as if i was insane like Mik (proud!)

plenty of options here, anyone care to give me the odds? :)
dont worry mik

we'll mob them all

Re: NJD/PIT/FLA 3-Way Night

PostedCOLON Thu Feb 07, 2013 5:58 pm
by The BBKL Insider
Peter wroteCOLON Neal > Laich
Brouwer > Bozak
i agree with this statement

and Shiv ended up with who? Laich and Brouwer? so he wins one and loses the other