Rate Your Prospects 2

[Da_Hawks]

Hawks top 10 Prospects

1st round pick 2019
Kristian Vesalainen
Bode Wilde
Isaac Lundestrom
Maxime Comtois
Brendan Guhle
Lucas Johansen
Jonatan Berggren
Dominik Bokk
Kale Kossila

Graduated: Cholowski, Dickinson, Georgiev,

I mean if we are adding our 1sts this year to the pile...lol! Better than a lot of lists so far.

Only added my 1st because the player is guaranteed to be my TOP prospect. Unless some guy comes around and talks me out of drafting 4th overall...

[kimmer]

Unless the pick becomes anoth3r griffin reinhart

[Da_Hawks]

Unless the pick becomes anoth3r griffin reinhart

He was still a top prospect when he was drafted. My list could very easily be complete shit in 3-4 years.

[hong57]

Hayton
Samsonov
Veleno
benson
kaut

vilardi if his back can recover...

[Shep]

I don't know

[kimmer]

Svech is 22 yrs old and would have had a full NHL season under his belt if not for ACL repair
Too old to b a prospect

Technically he still is. He's only played 16 games and hasn't established a full time role. And there are plenty of prospects that have broken out after 22.

Ya
Like i said.
16 gp and havent established role... Because ACL repair lol. Hello
Implication is that yes, he wudve been full time if not for ACL

[CasperX22]

Top 5 prospects:
1: I
2: Don't
3: Own
4: Any
5: Prospects

Favourite Prospects:
1: Jesperi Kotkaniemi
2: Alex Formenton
3: Dillon Dube
4: Alex Barre Boulet
5: Lukas Dostal

Flyers GM should hit me up if I ever get a team.

Kotkaniemi not a prospect

[thom54]

1. Jack Hughes/Kappo
2. Saarela
3. Ho-Sang
4. Poturalski
5. Golyshev
6. Cockerill
7. ah crap - controversial ranking

[CasperX22]

Svech is 22 yrs old and would have had a full NHL season under his belt if not for ACL repair
Too old to b a prospect

Technically he still is. He's only played 16 games and hasn't established a full time role. And there are plenty of prospects that have broken out after 22.

Ya
Like i said.
16 gp and havent established role... Because ACL repair lol. Hello
Implication is that yes, he wudve been full time if not for ACL

But...he did get hurt rendering him still a prospect. Jack Hughes will be assumed to have an NHL right away, so is he not a prospect? I guess you can define it however you like, but in the technical term he still is for at least a little while longer.

[CasperX22]

1. Jack Hughes/Kappo
2. Saarela
3. Ho-Sang
4. Poturalski
5. Golyshev
6. Cockerill
7. ah crap - controversial ranking

Yikes.

[kyuss]

Rank your best 5 prospects:
1. Kakko/Hughes
2. Kirill Kaprizov
3. Eeli Tolvanen
4. Nikita Gusev
5. K.A. Miller

Who are your 3 most underrated prospects?
1. Filip Hallander
2. Niklas Nordgren
3. Jan Jenìk

[Handsome&FairMike]

Rank your best 5 prospects:
1. Kakko/Hughes
2. Kirill Kaprizov
3. Eeli Tolvanen
4. Nikita Gusev
5. K.A. Miller

Who are your 3 most underrated prospects?
1. Filip Hallander
2. Niklas Nordgren
3. Jan Jenìk

Gross - Mik has a team of NHL "prospects" and Prospect "prospects"... Elite forever. When you gonna put it all together and win one man?

[CasperX22]

Would help if guys quit trading Mik all of their 1st round picks.

[kyuss]

Gross - Mik has a team of NHL "prospects" and Prospect "prospects"... Elite forever. When you gonna put it all together and win one man?

well it's not like I've not been trying...

#fail

[Matthew]

I'm going to win the bbkl cup before mik does, which probably means mik will never win it.

[kyuss]

Jeez that sounds awful

[Loki]

Rank your best 5 prospects:
1. Quinn Hughes
2. Jason Robertson
3. Jake Bean
4. Cam Dineen
5. Alexandre Fortin

[Sensfanjosh]

Good idea Matthew! I'll follow your model.

Prospect being a player who has played less than 25 NHL GP?

Rank your best 5 prospects:
1. Thatcher Demko (played in 9 NHL games)
2. Aleksi Heponiemi (16 + 30 = 46 pts in 50 gp for Karpat as a rookie in Liiga)
3. Alexandre Texier (14 + 27 = 41 pts in 55 gp for Kalpa in his second Liiga season, turned pro going 5 + 2 = 7 pts in 7 gp in the AHL, 1 + 0 = 1 pt in 2 NHL regular season games and 2 + 1 = 3 pts in 8 NHL playoff games)
4. MacKenzie Blackwood (played in 23 NHL games as a rookie, posting a 2.61 GAA, .918 save percentage for the rebuilding Devils)
5. Rasmus Kupari (12 + 21 = 33 pts in 43 gp for Karpat in his second Liiga season)

Who are your 3 most underrated prospects?
1. Alexander 'Sasha' Chmelevski (35 + 40 = 75 pts in 56 gp in the OHL, 10 + 18 = 28 pts in 15 gp in the OHL playoffs, and 4 + 3 = 7 pts in 7 gp for USA at the WJC)
2. Phillipe Kurashev (29 + 36 = 65 pts in 59 gp in the QMJHL, 1 + 4 = 5 pts in 7 gp in the QMJHL playoffs, 6 + 1 = 7 pts in 7 gp for Switzerland at the WJC)
3. Kirill Maksimov (40 + 39 = 79 pts in 63 gp in the OHL)

Who are your 5 Favorite Prospects (on other people's teams)?
1. Erik Brannstrom
2. Martin Necas
3. Otto Koivula
4. Akil Thomas
5. Matej Pekar

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
My 2017 list:

Rank your best 5 prospects:
1. Thatcher Demko
2. Aleksi Heponiemi
3. Alexandre Texier
4. Wade Allison
5. Jack Dougherty

Who are your 3 most underrated prospects?
1. Aleksi Heponiemi
2. Christian Jaros
3. Ryan Donato

Dougherty had a really bad year, but other than that and Allison's injury I'm pretty happy with my picks/ lists.

[cliff11]

Heres my list

1. Martin Necas
2. Just Valimaki
3. Timothy Liljegren
4. Kailer Yamamoto
5. Ian Scott

I also have a ton of youth who are already playing in the National League

[Florida Chris]

Ouch, my specs are bad. Best be keeping my picks in the next couple of drafts. Here are my top 10....Never mind could barely get a top 5.


1. Alex Nedeljkovic
2. Alexander Nylander
3. Michael Bunting
4. Mitchell Vande Sompel
5. Ryan Collins