Dubnyk vs Saros

Anything goes here OT stuff is OK too!

Who do you think has more value in BBKL?

Dubnyk
13
76%
Saros
4
24%
 
Total votesCOLON 17

User avatar
Bruyns
PostsCOLON 7177
JoinedCOLON Wed Apr 10, 2013 10:18 am

Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by Bruyns »

As requested
User avatar
Da_Hawks
PostsCOLON 2706
JoinedCOLON Mon Dec 18, 2017 9:27 am
LocationCOLON Ottawa

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by Da_Hawks »

Are we assuming the team for which they play for ONLY has those two starting? If so then Dubnyk... if not then Saros because he puts up better numbers when he does play... because well.. Dubnyk is bad at hockey.
Image
User avatar
CasperX22
PostsCOLON 6136
JoinedCOLON Sun Jan 11, 2015 12:37 pm

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by CasperX22 »

Da_Hawks wroteCOLONAre we assuming the team for which they play for ONLY has those two starting? If so then Dubnyk... if not then Saros because he puts up better numbers when he does play... because well.. Dubnyk is bad at hockey.
It's a fairly simple question. It's a matter of who you think is a more valuable player. Considering this is a dynasty league, talent, age, contract, situation, depth chart status, performance, etc everything should be considered.
User avatar
Matthew
PostsCOLON 13682
JoinedCOLON Wed Oct 08, 2014 3:29 pm

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by Matthew »

I'd say dubnyk. If saros can take a starting job for a year and do well then him. But lots of part time goalies put up great stats, get a full time job, and crash.

Dubnyk has a great contract for what he currently brings to bbkl.
ANAHEIM DUCKS | FANTRAX |
User avatar
Da_Hawks
PostsCOLON 2706
JoinedCOLON Mon Dec 18, 2017 9:27 am
LocationCOLON Ottawa

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by Da_Hawks »

Assuming Dubnyk still gets the lion's share of the starts, he has more value - and quite easily IMO. Saros is not guaranteed any starts. His age and team he plays behind plays against him in this case. Until a goalie is the starter, his value isn't worth what is being asked of IMO.

If Saros was the starter - his value is immense. But that won't be for another year or two. Until then, he's a really good backup with potential. Anyone who pays 7th overall + for him is crazy. Then again, I'm new.
Image
Lee
PostsCOLON 16828
JoinedCOLON Tue Jun 15, 2010 12:29 pm

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by Lee »

I'd pay it, just not 7th + another lottery pick + TT
User avatar
Matthew
PostsCOLON 13682
JoinedCOLON Wed Oct 08, 2014 3:29 pm

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by Matthew »

Lee wroteCOLONI'd pay it, just not 7th + another lottery pick + TT
Yes, this seems insane. But its his goalie so he can do what he wants with it. Perhaps he actually wants to keep him and this is the price to make him move saros. Just means you can get a cheaper goalie elsewhere.
ANAHEIM DUCKS | FANTRAX |
User avatar
CasperX22
PostsCOLON 6136
JoinedCOLON Sun Jan 11, 2015 12:37 pm

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by CasperX22 »

Matthew wroteCOLON
Lee wroteCOLONI'd pay it, just not 7th + another lottery pick + TT
Yes, this seems insane. But its his goalie so he can do what he wants with it. Perhaps he actually wants to keep him and this is the price to make him move saros. Just means you can get a cheaper goalie elsewhere.
Or you guys can just miss goalie gp starts. That's another possibility.
Lee
PostsCOLON 16828
JoinedCOLON Tue Jun 15, 2010 12:29 pm

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by Lee »

Matthew wroteCOLON
Lee wroteCOLONI'd pay it, just not 7th + another lottery pick + TT
Yes, this seems insane. But its his goalie so he can do what he wants with it. Perhaps he actually wants to keep him and this is the price to make him move saros. Just means you can get a cheaper goalie elsewhere.

You would think so, but I just got offered Pekka Rinne or Jacob Markstrom (from another GM that doesn't even own them) for Kotkaniemi
User avatar
Matthew
PostsCOLON 13682
JoinedCOLON Wed Oct 08, 2014 3:29 pm

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by Matthew »

CasperX22 wroteCOLON
Matthew wroteCOLON
Lee wroteCOLONI'd pay it, just not 7th + another lottery pick + TT
Yes, this seems insane. But its his goalie so he can do what he wants with it. Perhaps he actually wants to keep him and this is the price to make him move saros. Just means you can get a cheaper goalie elsewhere.
Or you guys can just miss goalie gp starts. That's another possibility.
True. Although I'm not in the saros market so the point is mute.
ANAHEIM DUCKS | FANTRAX |
User avatar
Bruyns
PostsCOLON 7177
JoinedCOLON Wed Apr 10, 2013 10:18 am

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by Bruyns »

Lee wroteCOLON
Matthew wroteCOLON
Lee wroteCOLONI'd pay it, just not 7th + another lottery pick + TT
Yes, this seems insane. But its his goalie so he can do what he wants with it. Perhaps he actually wants to keep him and this is the price to make him move saros. Just means you can get a cheaper goalie elsewhere.

You would think so, but I just got offered Pekka Rinne or Jacob Markstrom (from another GM that doesn't even own them) for Kotkaniemi
I'd also trade you Ryan Miller for him.
User avatar
Matthew
PostsCOLON 13682
JoinedCOLON Wed Oct 08, 2014 3:29 pm

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by Matthew »

Bruyns wroteCOLON
Lee wroteCOLON
Matthew wroteCOLON
Lee wroteCOLONI'd pay it, just not 7th + another lottery pick + TT
Yes, this seems insane. But its his goalie so he can do what he wants with it. Perhaps he actually wants to keep him and this is the price to make him move saros. Just means you can get a cheaper goalie elsewhere.

You would think so, but I just got offered Pekka Rinne or Jacob Markstrom (from another GM that doesn't even own them) for Kotkaniemi
I'd also trade you Ryan Miller for him.
Ben Scrivens also available if you can sweeten the deal a bit.
ANAHEIM DUCKS | FANTRAX |
User avatar
CasperX22
PostsCOLON 6136
JoinedCOLON Sun Jan 11, 2015 12:37 pm

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by CasperX22 »

Matthew wroteCOLON
CasperX22 wroteCOLON
Matthew wroteCOLON
Lee wroteCOLONI'd pay it, just not 7th + another lottery pick + TT
Yes, this seems insane. But its his goalie so he can do what he wants with it. Perhaps he actually wants to keep him and this is the price to make him move saros. Just means you can get a cheaper goalie elsewhere.
Or you guys can just miss goalie gp starts. That's another possibility.
True. Although I'm not in the saros market so the point is mute.
But I do assume you are in the goalie market.
User avatar
kyuss
PostsCOLON 14876
JoinedCOLON Thu May 06, 2010 12:54 pm

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by kyuss »

I guess the difference between Markstrom/Rinne and Miller/Saros is that the firsts are starters whereas the latters are backups
Lee
PostsCOLON 16828
JoinedCOLON Tue Jun 15, 2010 12:29 pm

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by Lee »

I like Markstrom but Josh has made it clear that Demko is not available so meh.
User avatar
Matthew
PostsCOLON 13682
JoinedCOLON Wed Oct 08, 2014 3:29 pm

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by Matthew »

CasperX22 wroteCOLON
Matthew wroteCOLON
CasperX22 wroteCOLON
Matthew wroteCOLON
Lee wroteCOLONI'd pay it, just not 7th + another lottery pick + TT
Yes, this seems insane. But its his goalie so he can do what he wants with it. Perhaps he actually wants to keep him and this is the price to make him move saros. Just means you can get a cheaper goalie elsewhere.
Or you guys can just miss goalie gp starts. That's another possibility.
True. Although I'm not in the saros market so the point is mute.
But I do assume you are in the goalie market.
Not especially.
ANAHEIM DUCKS | FANTRAX |
User avatar
CasperX22
PostsCOLON 6136
JoinedCOLON Sun Jan 11, 2015 12:37 pm

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by CasperX22 »

Rolling with Domingue+Casey DeSmith? Bold strategy.
User avatar
Bruyns
PostsCOLON 7177
JoinedCOLON Wed Apr 10, 2013 10:18 am

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by Bruyns »

You should be, I wouldn't want to miss out on a chance at Hughes.
User avatar
Da_Hawks
PostsCOLON 2706
JoinedCOLON Mon Dec 18, 2017 9:27 am
LocationCOLON Ottawa

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by Da_Hawks »

I did offer Lee Georgiev if he went out and acquired Hank, but that was a sound no. Doesn't seem like the options he likes are the options available. Gonna have to bit the bullet eventually.
Image
User avatar
Matthew
PostsCOLON 13682
JoinedCOLON Wed Oct 08, 2014 3:29 pm

Re: Dubnyk vs Saros

Post by Matthew »

CasperX22 wroteCOLONRolling with Domingue+Casey DeSmith? Bold strategy.
I think the goalie market isn't as bad as people think. Lots of people selling goalies and not a lot buying. I only need like 10 bad goalie gp. Eventually I may grab a cheap goalie, but not really interested atm. There is a ton of time.
ANAHEIM DUCKS | FANTRAX |
BUTTON_POST_REPLY

Return to